Set against the desolate backdrop of the Great Depression, Paper Moon (1973), directed by Peter Bogdanovich, is a black-and-white road movie that masterfully blends comedy, drama, and a touch of melancholy. The film follows the unlikely pairing of Moses Pray, a slick-talking Bible salesman and small-time con artist, and Addie Loggins, a recently orphaned nine-year-old girl who may or may not be his daughter. After attending her mother’s funeral, Moses is roped into taking Addie to her only known relative in St. Joseph, Missouri. Along the way, the two form an uneasy alliance as Addie quickly proves herself a savvy, shrewd, and resourceful grifter in her own right.
What begins as an obligatory escort mission evolves into a unique father-daughter dynamic, complicated by personal motives, shared mischief, and a refusal to be outsmarted—especially by each other. The pair drift from one small con to another, selling customized Bibles to widows, running bootleg liquor schemes, and navigating the rural Midwest’s desperate economic terrain. All the while, their bond deepens, both hardened and humanized by the grit of survival and the tenderness they struggle to express.
Character Study
Addie Loggins (Tatum O’Neal)
Addie is the soul of Paper Moon. Wise beyond her years, she is sharp-tongued, intuitive, and fiercely independent. Tatum O’Neal’s portrayal—one of the greatest child performances in cinema history—earned her the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress, making her the youngest winner in Oscar history at just 10 years old. Addie is no sentimental waif; she is tough, calculating, and emotionally guarded. She recognizes the harshness of the world and adapts to it with startling acumen. Her cleverness often surpasses that of the adults around her, especially Moses, whom she constantly keeps on his toes.
What makes Addie such a compelling figure is the duality of her character. Beneath the poker-faced con artist is a little girl quietly longing for family, affection, and stability—things she is too proud to admit she needs. Her subtle gestures of vulnerability, such as saving money in a cigar box or protecting Moses from his own worst impulses, reveal a depth of emotional intelligence that contradicts her age.
Moses Pray (Ryan O’Neal)
Moses is a charming yet irresponsible drifter, a man whose life revolves around deception, survival, and avoidance of emotional entanglement. Ryan O’Neal plays him with a balance of charisma and irritation. While his initial interest in Addie seems mostly opportunistic—believing he can con her out of $200—he is gradually disarmed by her wit and resilience. Moses is not a villain; he’s simply a product of hard times, hustling to get by with whatever tools he has.
What defines Moses is his inconsistency. He wavers between wanting to ditch Addie and being genuinely protective of her. He resents her manipulations but also grows to respect them. His evolution is subtle and organic, and their final moments together—when he makes a choice that prioritizes connection over convenience—speak volumes about the quiet redemption at the heart of his character.
The film’s secondary characters, such as Trixie Delight (played with boisterous flair by Madeline Kahn), add both levity and depth to the journey. Trixie is a traveling showgirl Moses picks up along the way, and her clash with Addie is both comedic and revealing. Kahn imbues Trixie with an unexpected dignity that transcends her initial role as comic relief. Her character’s brief arc underscores the economic desperation and female agency rarely depicted with such empathy in films of this tone.
Paper Moon remains a resonant film not just because of its period detail or stylistic elegance, but because it explores themes of survival, deception, trust, and family with a sincerity that transcends its era. In today’s world—where economic instability, fractured families, and coming-of-age struggles are still commonplace—the film’s emotional undercurrents remain relevant.
The depiction of strong, complex child characters challenges conventional portrayals in media. Addie isn’t precocious in a cute or endearing way; she’s a survivalist, a girl forced into adulthood too soon. That still mirrors the reality many children face today in unstable environments, making her story one that speaks across generations.
The dynamic between Addie and Moses also raises questions about what constitutes family. Their relationship evolves from mutual exploitation into genuine affection, illustrating that love can grow in unlikely circumstances and that family isn’t always determined by blood.
Fun Facts
- The film was shot entirely in black-and-white, a deliberate choice by Bogdanovich to evoke the aesthetic of 1930s photography and add a timeless quality. Despite the era of Technicolor, the visual choice paid off, enhancing the film’s period authenticity.
- Tatum and Ryan O’Neal, who played Addie and Moses, were real-life father and daughter. This adds a fascinating layer to their on-screen chemistry, as their push-pull dynamic mirrors the complicated affection and tension of their off-screen relationship.
- Madeline Kahn was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress for her role as Trixie, showcasing her remarkable range and setting the stage for a career filled with standout performances.
- The film was based on the novel Addie Pray by Joe David Brown, but the title was changed to Paper Moon after the Hoagy Carmichael song of the same name, which is featured in the film. The song’s lyrics—”It’s only a paper moon… unless you believe in me”—perfectly encapsulate the central theme of illusion and belief, both in cons and in human connection.
Paper Moon is more than a nostalgic road movie. It’s a study in contrasts—between youth and adulthood, reality and illusion, loneliness and connection. It captures the harshness of an era without ever losing sight of humor or heart. Anchored by unforgettable performances, especially Tatum O’Neal’s quietly powerful turn as Addie, the film remains a testament to the enduring power of character-driven storytelling. Even decades later, its honesty, wit, and emotional depth continue to speak to audiences looking for meaning in life’s more rugged journeys.
The post Retro Movie Review: Paper Moon (1973) appeared first on cravedfw.